Confidential drug rebate hurts access to drugs and leads to overpayment – HEOR insights

Rebates is a common pricing technique to incentivize innovation in the scientific field, with  complex outcomes and interesting history. Payers (including government payers) commonly negotiate discounts (rebates) from manufacturers. In recent years, many European countries have negotiated rebates (in many cases confidential rebates) with an ultimate goal of keeping drug prices low and increasing drug access. Does such confidential rebate improve patient-access at a more affordable price? 

Using confidential-rebates has little impact on improving patient-access at more affordable prices, according to a new study from the University of Zurich published in the Lancet.

Introduced in 2012, rebates in Switzerland have been kept secret starting 2019. Carl et.al. investigated all the drugs with and without rebates between January 2012 and October 2020 to understand clinical benefits of drug with rebates, and duration between approval and price determination. 

This timely study concludes following

Drugs with rebates may hamper access to drugs and lead to overpayment. Improving transparency on actual drug prices and stronger cooperation between countries could help national authorities to make better informed pricing decisions, and improve access of innovative drugs to patients.

In addition to above mentioned issues related to rebates, the difference between listing price and secretly negotiated price poses complicated analysis issues. We agree with the researchers emphasis on adopting WHO’s resolution on drug pricing transparency. 

If history has taught us anything, it is that secret rebates create more problems than they solve in the long term (secrete rebates discussed in the famous Rockefeller’s Standard Oil Co v United States)

Source

Carl, D. L., & Vokinger, K. N. (2021). Patients’s access to drugs with rebates in Switzerland – Empirical analysis and policy implications for drug pricing in Europe. The Lancet Regional Health – Europe. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lanepe.2021.100050 (Accessed at https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7762(21)00027-2/fulltext#%20 )

spot_img

Explore more

The Stunning Pendulum Drawings of Swiss Healer and Artist Emma Kunz – The Marginalian

The Stunning Pendulum Drawings of Swiss Healer and Artist Emma Kunz...

Emma Kunz (May 23, 1892–January 16, 1963) was forty-six and the world was aflame with war when she became an artist. She had worked...

Can Dry Eyes Cause Blindness?

Dry eyes, medically known as keratoconjunctivitis sicca, aren’t just a fleeting discomfort; it’s a persistent issue that occurs when tears fail to provide adequate...

Why Do I Feel Nauseous?

Are you curious why you feel nauseous? Discover common causes of nausea, helpful tips on how to stop feeling nauseous, and even when to...
Simplified Sleep Solutions for Busy Women: Summertime Bedtime Rituals

Simplified Sleep Solutions for Busy Women: Summertime Bedtime Rituals

For many busy women, the idea of achieving a restful night’s sleep can feel like a distant dream. Juggling work, family, and personal commitments...
Why is my vagina dry during sex?

Why is my vagina dry during sex?

If you’re too embarrassed to ask your doctor (or anyone) the question:...
Inside the Factory Supplying Half of Africa’s Syringes

Inside the Factory Supplying Half of Africa’s Syringes

On the stunning Kenyan coast, about halfway between 15th-century ruins and the vibrant city of Mombasa, a small factory is helping to achieve one...

Dental SEO versus PPC: choosing the best strategy for your dental...

Shaz Memon weights up the pros and cons of dental SEO versus pay-per-click (PPC) advertising to work out which digital marketing model is best...
My Favorite Memorial Day Sales on Tablets

My Favorite Memorial Day Sales on Tablets

Today is Memorial Day, and many retailers are offering deals on laptops, TVs, headphones, Bluetooth speakers, smartphones, and tablets. If you want a new...